The 29-year-old Oscar-winning actress and the art dealer, 34, had a romantic dinner at NYC hotspot Cookshop where they enjoyed oysters and a bottle of wine, a source tells PEOPLE.

Gypsy-Rose Blanchard cooked a "romantic dinner" of spaghetti and meatballs for her boyfriend Ken Urker in a vlog posted to YouTube and TikTok on Aug. 30.