When the West Virginia alum, Pat McAfee, joined ESPN’s College GameDay, fans had plenty to say, and not all of it was kind.

Pat McAfee had a moment Tuesday morning that he randomly thought back to the classic Orange Bowl between Notre Dame and Penn State.

McAfee made a rare in-ring appearance against Gunther at WWE Backlash in May, a match that garnered a mixed reception from fans. The former Indianapolis Colts kicker showed a lack of physicality and ...